The strongest arguments for and against the existence of God | Alex O'Connor: Full Interview
In the compelling interview titled “The Strongest Arguments for and Against the Existence of God,” philosopher Alex O’Connor dives deep into the intricate questions surrounding belief, morality, and the universe’s foundational principles. O’Connor articulates the allure of existential meaning, positing that while many find comfort in the idea of a grand purpose, reliance solely on random chance leaves a sense of void.
Central to his discussion is the “first cause” argument, which he explains through a nuanced analysis of hierarchical causality. He contrasts traditional notions of causation with the idea that everything necessitates an underlying cause rooted in necessity; a perspective that dismisses infinite regress as untenable.
However, he acknowledges the powerful counterargument: the problem of suffering. O’Connor examines how the existence of a benevolent deity appears at odds with the overwhelming suffering observed in the world, thereby challenging conventional religious beliefs.
Furthermore, he explores nihilism, emphasizing the emotional undercurrents that guide our moral compasses. Emotivism emerges as a key theme, suggesting that moral judgments are reflections of our emotional responses rather than objective truths.
Ultimately, O’Connor invites viewers to grapple with their beliefs about God and morality, encouraging a profound exploration of their implications in our lives. This thought-provoking discussion provides a rich foundation for anyone seeking to understand the philosophical landscape of belief.
Watch the video by Big Think
Author Video Description
Become a Big Think member to unlock expert classes, premium print issues, exclusive events and more: https://bigthink.com/membership/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=yt_desc
“I think that there are very good arguments to believe that there are some kind of foundational principle of the universe, some necessarily existing being, some first cause.”
Subscribe to Big Think on YouTube ► https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCvQECJukTDE2i6aCoMnS-Vg?sub_confirmation=1
Up next, How to grow deeply happy | Jonny Thomson ► https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WShJeNX7W8
Instead of treating belief as a private preference, philosopher Alex O’Connor examines how our moral positions shape institutions, obligations, and the ways we justify our choices.
His arguments invite a closer look at why we hold certain principles, and whether those principles survive contact with their real-world consequences.
00:00 The lure of meaning
01:15 The strongest arguments for and against the existence of God
03:38 Hierarchical causes and borrowed causal power
06:33 Sustaining causes and necessity of foundation
10:04 How classical thinkers framed the first cause
14:27 Suffering as the challenge to God
17:42 Between classical theism, deism, and atheism
20:58 Understanding nihilism and the human condition
24:36 Self-justifying motives and meaning
28:00 Meaning in a materialist world
31:41 Ecclesiastes and the first nihilist
36:38 Why stories explain what logic can’t
48:55 Emotion’s grip on belief
54:20 How emotivism shapes ethics
1:05:18 Where morality meets emotion
Read the video transcript ► https://bigthink.com/series/full-interview/first-cause-argument/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=video&utm_campaign=youtube_description
© Freethink Media Inc., All Rights Reserved.
———————————————————————————-
Go Deeper with Big Think:
►Become a Big Think Youtube Member
Get exclusive classes and early, ad-free access to new releases without leaving Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/@bigthink/membership/
►Become a Big Think Web Member
Get the entire Big Think Class library, premium print issues, live events, and more.
►Subscribe to Big Think on Substack
Get all of your favorite Big Think content delivered to your inbox.
https://bigthinkmedia.substack.com/subscribe/
———————————————————————————-
About Alex O’Connor:
Alex O’Connor, also known as Cosmic Skeptic, is an English public speaker and content creator recognized for his work on philosophy, ethics, religion, and secularism. He hosts the podcast Within Reason
About Big Think
Big Think is the leading source of expert-driven, actionable, educational content — with thousands of videos, featuring experts ranging from Bill Clinton to Bill Nye, we help you get smarter, faster. Get actionable lessons from the world’s greatest thinkers & doers. Our experts are either disrupting or leading their respective fields.
Video “The strongest arguments for and against the existence of God | Alex O'Connor: Full Interview” was uploaded on 11/27/2025 to Youtube Channel Big Think