Video Description: I Tested the Most Famous Food in NYC vs Chicago
In this exciting new video, we embark on a culinary adventure pitting two of America’s most iconic cities against each other: New York City and Chicago! 🍕🥯 From the classic bagels and pizza of NYC to the deep-dish delights of Chicago, we’re diving into what makes each city’s food scene so special.
A huge thank you to Square for partnering with us on this episode! Don’t miss out on exclusive savings of up to $200 on Square hardware—check out my link here: https://timf.io/4rO1pdu!
Joining me on this delicious journey are my co-hosts, @ChrisDolo and @TheDonChicago, who help me bring the flavors of each city to life. Will NYC’s famed pizza hold its ground against Chicago’s hearty deep-dish? Or will the Big Apple’s bagels steal the show?
Be sure to tune in as we taste our way through #NYC and #Chicago, and find out which city takes the crown in this epic food face-off!
Don’t forget to follow me on Instagram for more behind-the-scenes content: http://www.instagram.com/here.be.barr
Let’s dig in! 🍴✨
NYCFood #ChicagoFood #FoodWars #ad @square
Watch the video by Jon Barr
Video “I Tested the Most Famous Food in NYC vs Chicago” was uploaded on 11/20/2026. Watch all the latest Videos by Jon Barr on Gretopia





































first
A classic plain foldable slice from Luigi's Pizza in Brooklyn, made with Italian tomatoes and Grande cheese, is entirely made with love and passion
I think you're too biased to judge this contest.
Chicago has the Italian Beef (get it dipped; not a take-out food).. but NY City has better pizza..buuut my favorite Pizza is in Smyrna, Ga.; LaBelle. Owned by a local NYorker.
nobody in chicago eats deep dish please stop propagating this myth its ridiculous
Jon, a moment. Every YouTube food channel has done the NYC pizza vs. Chicago deep dish bit. Deep dish is fine, but NYC pizza wins every time & it's not even close. So here's a real challenge. NYC pizza vs. Montreal pizza. Do that next & tell us what you think. Thanks.
Deep dish pizza is for tourists, I’m not sure why every YouTuber gets this wrong, probably because tavern style would wipe the floor with NY style.
Love watching your vids
I like your content a lot but seeing UNO’s as the deep dish pick is so funny. And as other commenters have said, “tavern style” or square cut is the Chicago style we eat regularly. It’s thin crust and would’ve been a better comparison to a NY slice.
I need to come to Chicago just for that Italian Beef sandwich omgggggggg looks incredible! 😅
Man needs a few days of fast
Hi Jon:
Great video (as always).
Kudos on staying fit and trim. Ain't easy for a food reviewer.
I dream of going to nyc nd enjoy a slice of pie
I will always call it soda
no ketchup because the relish brings the sweetness
I'll ALWAYS put ketchup on my hot dawg. You shouldn't food shame, Jon. 🙄🙄
Pizzaaaaàà or sandwiches ?
love this concept…cant wait to see all the fights in the comments! 🎉
It would be interesting to see you try the most notorious food instead.
I vote for New York
If nuclear war breaks out i hope Chicago gets hit…im downstate and taking
out chicago would benefit everyone and i will always put ketchup on my hotdogs even if i dont like it cause you people are insufferable and shoukd be snuffed out
Nobody from Chicago actually eats deep dish easiest way to spot a tourist. It’s all about the tavern style for locals.
18:56 those prices hurt to look at
Jon, Pro Tip… running thru the garden is a lot. Mustard, Relish, Onion, Sport Pepper is the way to go. take off the pickle and tomato slices
@HereBeBarr you’ll probably hear this from the comments, but Chicagoan's rarely eat deep dish. That’s more of a special-occasion thing, usually when people are visiting. As a city-dweller I can’t remember the last time we had it. Don’t get me wrong, it’s delicious, but thin crust (tavern-style) is the everyday pie. 🍕
Hilarious part: Jon say about the cheesecake – I think this is going to be the hardest one for me to pick – and right next to him are two Chicago guys you wouldn't want to mess with in a dark alley!
Another video, another visit to gray’s papaya… 🤣🤣
While I love Gray's Papaya, I don't know why you didn't choose Nathan's on Coney Island for this contest. Gray's uses Sabrett hot dogs; Nathan's uses their own make and recipe. It's not the same.
As a native New Yorker, I unequivocally prefer deep-dish pizza. I absolutely love it! But at the end of the day, taste is subjective. We all have different preferences, and there's room for everyone. We don't need to knock one city's food to celebrate another's. And specifically, when it comes to pizza, I find the argument that deep-dish isn't "real pizza" silly. Why can't people accept that pizza evolves? There are different styles, regional interpretations, and variations. I'm sure there are Italians in Italy who would argue that New York-style pizza isn't real pizza either. The point is, food evolves, and that's okay! Pizza is allowed to be regional, and one style doesn't invalidate another. There's room for everybody!
NY Pizza vs. quiche
Great video, but as a Chicagoan, I mean no disrespect to your “Chicago food guests”, but I’m not sure any Chicagoan has been to UNO’s more than once, Dog House is ok, but there are 300 better dog spots. Also, a depression dog is onion, sport pepper, relish and mustard, not grilled onion, mustard and sport pepper…. unless you’re going to a Maxwell street spot.
Also, all the people saying Chicagoans don’t eat deep dish aren’t from Chicago. We eat it, but not as often. It’s a craving thing. But to say we don’t eat it, is a lie.
I love NY Pizza & I love Chicago DD Pizza. I love pizza.
Leave it to dolo to not even get the proper history right lmfao, during the Great Depression it was believed ketchup was used to mask the taste of poor quality meat. So all of the vendors who took pride in their high quality meat would slowly begin to stop adding ketchup as a way to display the quality of meat they had and as time went on that tradition stood tall.
Born and raised Chicagoans eat thin crust, tourists eat deep dish pizza and that's fine! That's why I love NY pizza!♥🍎
"What goes in your sauce?"
"Tomatoes"
chicago dog all the way
Next time you go to get a beef — Johnnie's Beef!
Definitely should of been a tie !
I didn't think NYC would beat Chicago in hot dogs. However, if you were in Brooklyn already for Luigi, why not run to Nathans in coney island for the most classic and best dog in NYC? Also, I think tavern style in Chicago is way better than the deep dish and stacks up better against our pizza, but still would lose.
Thank GOD you didn’t go to Juniors!