Netanyahu’s Push for US Strikes Puts World in a ‘Damned If You Do’ Dilemma on Iran: Analysis
In a recent Al Jazeera interview, Israeli analyst Akiva Elder presented a sobering critique of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s aggressive stance on Iran, particularly concerning potential military strikes by the United States. Elder’s insights highlight the deep-rooted complexities of the Israel-Iran conflict and the broader implications of military intervention.
Elder noted that many politicians in the U.S. have historically lauded former President Donald Trump’s hardline approach toward Iran, yet often overlook the long-term ramifications of such policies. He emphasized that while strikes may offer a temporary sense of security or victory, they ignore the necessity for a comprehensive political solution, a reality starkly reflected in Israel’s ongoing conflicts since 1967.
A significant point raised by Elder was the warning from Israeli opposition leader Yair Golan. Golan underscored that wars are not resolved through military might alone, a caution that resonates deeply in the context of the Middle East’s volatile landscape. Elder voiced his concerns that any potential regime change in Iran could unleash chaos reminiscent of the aftermaths seen in Iraq and Libya, underscoring the unpredictable nature of such military engagements.
Furthermore, Elder criticized Netanyahu’s focus on achieving a "total victory," both in Gaza and against Iran, questioning the wisdom of such ambitions. He suggested that this kind of mindset might overlook critical factors that contribute to lasting peace and stability in the region.
One of the most alarming aspects of Elder’s analysis is the potential for regional destabilization as a result of U.S. military involvement. He warned of scenarios like the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, a vital chokepoint for global oil shipments, which could exacerbate international economic tensions and lead to wider conflict.
The analyst also raised doubts about the feasibility of establishing stability in Iran even if its current government were to collapse. He pointed out that Israel seems to prioritize military victories over exit strategies, resulting in conflicts that remain unresolved and perpetually fraught with tension.
Elder’s insights present a compelling narrative, brimming with cautionary lessons about the intricate connections between military actions and the pursuit of long-term peace. The challenge facing leaders, both in Israel and the U.S., will be navigating these turbulent waters, where each decision carries the weight of potentially unpredictable global consequences.
Watch the video by Al Jazeera English
Video “Netanyahu's push for US strikes puts world in a 'damned if you do' dilemma on Iran: Analysis” was uploaded on 06/22/2025 to Youtube Channel Al Jazeera English