Ukraine is currently facing a crucial decision regarding its valuable raw materials and national security. According to Donald Trump’s national security adviser Mike Waltz, Ukraine may agree to a deal where it trades its extensive underground reserves of minerals, including lithium, cobalt, and rare-earths like scandium, in exchange for security guarantees from the United States.
These raw materials are essential for various industries, from defense to electric vehicles, making them highly sought after on the global market. However, Ukrainian President Zelenskyy has reportedly rejected a draft proposal that would have given Washington half of the income from these resources in exchange for military aid that the US has already provided.
The situation raises questions about Ukraine’s sovereignty and the implications of potentially giving up control over its valuable resources in exchange for security assurances. It also highlights the complex dynamics at play in international relations, particularly in a region that has been at the center of geopolitical tensions.
Gracelin Baskaran from the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) provides insights into the implications of such a deal in the video, emphasizing the importance of Ukraine’s mineral wealth and the potential consequences of trading it for security guarantees.
As Ukraine navigates these negotiations and weighs its options, the outcome could have far-reaching implications for both the country’s economic future and its national security. The issue remains a contentious topic that will continue to be closely monitored by observers and analysts.
Watch the video by DW News
Video “Will Ukraine agree to trade its valuable raw materials for security guarantees? | DW News” was uploaded on 02/22/2025 to Youtube Channel DW News
The blame is on Zelensky on why we have this mess. He cancelled the Rare Earth Metals deal which if you look at it would bring Ukraine its importance at par with Taiwan. US will never put in writing security assurances especially in peace negotiations. But this deal would have given justification for US to protect its assets in the future. This is the hidden understanding with no writing required. Zelensky chose to humiliate Trump in public by cancelling the deal instead of negotiating it. Totally amateur leader that definitely doesn't deserve a seat in the first round of talks with Russia. And what does he get by doing this? Trump's rant! And now Trump is hinting for an election to replace Zelensky with someone that can read between the lines. Meanwhile Russia still pushing aggressively as time goes and with many more lives wasted. Ukrainians next gen is at the brink of extinction.
Nothing is FREE in life.
Europe wants its money back but us Americans can’t ask for the same got it 😂 he better come up with 500 billions 🦅🇺🇸🇺🇸
So Ukraine is graped militarily by Russia and will be graped economicly by murica
Ukraine can say no, and they should say no. Who has attacked Ukraine? Russia.
Don't give in to demands in exchange for nothing. I hope that Europe can step in to to make up for the lost support so that the U.S. can be ignored while its government acts like this.
Why should Ukraine pay reparations ??? Russia should return stolen land and pay reparations. Hold strong Ukraine !!!
Extortion. Shameful.
If deal is not done then of course US will not give any weapons aid.. And sooner or later 🇷🇺 will capture that sites..
Instead of begging every time 🇺🇦 must make a deal.. EVERYTHING HAS A PRICE & THAT’S THE BUSINESS💯
Security guarantees are a fantasy.
US can't ask funds for help already issued! First of all it WAS HELP, not trade!!! Second, in the words of racists (so they comprehend) "don't be an indian giver"…
I am with Ukraine but maybe 50% is not bad because USA will do minerals exploitation, industrial conversions, sales or uses of those materials. I was opposed to Mr Trump offer, but maybe it is a great opportunity for Ukraine to finish the war, and to become a rich country. I think Zelensky could be happy signing Trump’s offer but he needs detailed guarantees about Ukraine
The WHOLE WORLD "IS VERY FRUSTRATED" with Putler's Aggression. He DEMOLISHED HALF OF SYRIA, part of Georgia Republic, and Chechnya. Then moved to Ukraina. The Monster can't sit still and live in Peace.
In the middle of the Covid Pandemic suffering, Inflation soaring, this WAR CRIMINAL WAGES ANOTHER WAR.
INSTEAD OF BLAMING UKRAINE FOR BEING ATTACKED, WHO DO YOU THINK "YOU SHOULD" BE BLAMING???
The answer should be:
Will people from the US eventually force their president to get it over with this clownesque extortion act?
This zelenski wants all the freebies??? Ridiculous!
I Wonder what else did you guys expect ? Russia to loose this one ?
Damn you seem to be more ignorant and naiv than a 5 year old …
Putin reacted with aggression towards broken agreements and you wonder why he doesn’t back down ? He lost all trust in the west and we make it worse every day ignoring him and calling him evil …
That’s not how the real world works !
This is seriously a joke how the eu handled any of this in first place
Ukraine lost. Pay up.
Is Russia. IT was not Russian. EU and US 🤨🤨🤨
He needs to take care of Ukraine not the US or Russia
The Melon Felon is so out of it. A bit of critical thinking is required by everyone on this matter. First, Canada is happy to supply the US with all of these critical minerals they require, but the Pumpkin Spiced Palpatine has threatened 25% tariffs on them. Second, the US imported $120M worth of rare earth products in 2023, so the $500Bn the Tangerine Tyrant is demanding from Ukraine would take over 2,000 years to repay at current consumption rates.
The average reader does not understand that an ounce of gold IN THE GROUND is worth about $10 when it comes to making a deal on the property. To go from in the ground to in your hand takes years of environmental and engineering studies, someone has to break it out, process it and refine it ALL OF WHICH COSTS MONEY.
For AID given by Biden with No obligation to pay back, Ukraine owns nothing to USA!!!!
Nothing!!
I Wonder what else did you guys expect ? Russia to loose this one ?
Damn you seem to be more ignorant and naiv than a 5 year old …
Putin reacted with aggression towards broken agreements and you wonder why he doesn’t back down ? He lost all trust in the west and we make it worse every day ignoring him and calling him evil …
That’s not how the real world works !
This is seriously a joke how the eu handled any of this in first place
Is Lake Baikal on the table?
America wants her money back
raw materials are for president elon
*Never trust trump
Ukraine has zero leverage. Any European NATO member maybe delusional enough to start WW3. US will not join.
Russia is the aggressor in a war defending its interest and made agreements with the west
There was a security guarantee that US promised in the 90’s when Ukrainians gave up their nuclear weapons. 😅
This is pure blackmailing by Donald Trump.
Maybe China will offer Ukraine a cheaper deall than 50% , seeing that they have expressed willingness to participate in the peacemaking/peacekeeping?
Maybe throw in another discount for joining BRICS while they're at it…
I don't understand. Where's the EU in this contract?
China is evil. US is emulating. Welcome to to the era of dictators.