Baking an Incredible Cranberry Pie from 1796: A Journey Through Time
As the crisp air of autumn settles in, and leaves painting the landscape in hues of gold and crimson begin to fall, it brings to mind not only the beauty of the season but also the beloved traditions that accompany it. One such cherished tradition is the art of baking, a practice that connects us to our ancestors and allows us to bring the warmth of home into our lives. This Thanksgiving, let’s take a step back in time and dive into the delightful experience of creating a historical treasure: a Cranberry Pie from 1796.
A Taste of History
Imagine a time over two centuries ago when simple ingredients were transformed into exquisite dishes that brought families together. This cranberry pie, or tart depending on how you choose to view it, is a celebration of the past—bridging generations and passing down stories with every bite. As we prepare this remarkable dessert, we embrace the flavors and techniques of our forebears, infusing our modern gatherings with a sense of nostalgia and innovation.
The Magic of Ingredients
Gather your ingredients, for each one has a story to tell:
- Fresh Cranberries: Nature’s gems, bursting with tart sweetness, embody the spirit of gratitude and abundance.
- Sugar: A scoop of sweetness that adjusts the tartness of our protagonist, the cranberry.
- Butter: The rich, creamy base that adds depth to our crust, whispering secrets of countless holiday feasts.
- Flour: Ground from the harvest, it binds everything together, symbolizing unity and the heart of family meals.
- Spices: A sprinkle of cinnamon and nutmeg evokes warm, cozy memories, enveloping us in a comforting embrace.
Crafting the Pie
-
Prepare the Crust: Start with a classic pie crust, made from flour, butter, and a pinch of salt. Knead the dough with care, envisioning the hands of those who came before you, each fold and roll echoing the past.
-
Prepare the Filling: As you combine the fresh cranberries with sugar and spices, take a moment to inhale the intoxicating aroma. This is the essence of joy, memories waiting to be created, as you mix well, ensuring all the flavors meld together.
-
Bake Over Fire: Using a traditional baking method over an open flame, set your pie in a makeshift baking vessel—this is where the magic truly happens. Listening to the gentle crackle of the fire and the bubbling of your pie is like a natural melody, an ASMR experience connecting you to the generations that baked before you.
-
The Finished Masterpiece: Once golden and bubbling, allow your cranberry pie to cool, letting anticipation build. As you slice into it, reveal the stunning ruby-red filling, glimmering with thanksgiving blessings.
Bringing It to the Table
As you present this beautiful cranberry pie to your family, share the history and stories behind its creation. Encourage each person to take a moment to express what they are grateful for this season. In this way, not only do your taste buds savor the delightful tartness, but your hearts are also filled with appreciation for connection.
This year, as you gather around the table with loved ones, let this cranberry pie be more than just a dessert. Let it be a symbol of togetherness, a connection to the past, and an inspiring invitation to create new traditions that can be shared over generations to come.
May each slice remind you that the essence of family and gratitude is what makes the harvest truly abundant. Enjoy this historical delicacy, and watch as it transforms into a beloved tradition in your own home!
Watch the video by Early American
Video “Baking an Incredible Cranberry Pie from 1796 |Real Historic Dishes| Fire Baked Pie ASMR” was uploaded on 11/18/2026 to Youtube Channel Early American





































That is a cool looking pie. It looks like it was a hit with Bubba and Ron.
I'm bringing this to thanksgivign dinner this year! We'll see what everyone thinks of it.
Yummy jewel christmassy colour ❤
you look like Bryan Johnson from the side 😆
Beautiful as always. I always wonder when I watch these how they washed their dishes without running water. What a mess to wash eggs, dough, sticky cranberries off all of that!
lol bubba be like why you eat my tart Ron be like boop lol
Yum I would have preferred the ones with brown sugar I think. I love brown sugar in an apple pie too.
Well I do enjoy me some cranberry sauce lol.
Does it taste like Ocean Spray cranberry sauce served in a crust?
Justine, this is so neat getting the video when I was not expecting one! Pie is beautiful! I love surprise videos!
YUMMY Cranberry/Jello pie! 🙂
I wonder if you can use cranberries as a lovely natural dye for fabric's😊💖.
Hi Justine….what a beautiful recipe!….and little Ron looking as handsome as ever-enjoying pie!❤️❤️❤️❤️….I love cranberries, and have made plenty of cranberry bread!❤️❤️❤️👌👌👌
Love watching Justine cook authentically. I really appreciate the great videography & the sounds of this one especially👌 You do a really nice job with the camera work & audio! I enjoy this channel for its unique content & its really interesting learning about what past lives looked like. You definitely found your niche!
I’ve never wanted a pie thrown in my face as bad as I want THAT PIE thrown into my face! 🤤
That looks delicious! I love cranberries but it looks like it takes a lot.
Lil' Bubba is getting so big! Is it time for a sibling???? (~_^)🤞😊(ㅅ´ ˘ `)
Cranberry Pie approved by family! Looks good….👍
Those look delicious 😊
These pies looks gorges also the coloring of them! Looked like the family are enjoying themselves! These pies could become a family and holiday treteration! Rebecca and David Back.
Hey actually real clothing plus real real food! That is news! Everyone else is claiming zio nazi or death so death it is!
Amazing color. 🎉🎉🎉
Ooh that looks good!! And I love the music at the end! 😊
i love how the music slowly dims to allow the natural sounds to proliferate ,,, beautiful pie! And amazing video! That is one stunning Red pie
The recipe 😃translated into modern instructions from the 1796 original which you can find at the end of the video. Thank you for joining me today! My name is Justine Rayfield and I LOVE recreating these antique recipes and trying them out with you all. It's a fun experiment and shows us how food has changed over the centuries.
Cranberries (American Cookery, 1796)
Ingredients:
– 4 cups fresh or frozen cranberries
– ½ cup water
– 1-1.5 cups white granulated sugar (adjust to taste. Substitute with brown sugar if you're more interested in the version from 1805)
– Pastry dough for a single 9-inch tart
Instructions:
1. Place the clean, washed cranberries and water in a saucepan over medium heat. Simmer until the cranberries soften and burst, about 20 minutes.
2. Press the cooked cranberries through a fine-mesh sieve to remove the skins and seeds, collecting the smooth cranberry pulp. Sieves in this time were made from horse hair!
3. While still warm, stir in the white sugar until completely dissolved. Taste and add more sugar if desired. Cranberries require A LOT of sugar.
4. Line a 9-inch tart pan with pastry dough.
5. Pour the sweetened cranberry mixture into the pastry shell and spread evenly.
6. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for approximately 30–40 minutes, or until the pastry is golden and the filling is set.
7. Allow to cool overnight so the cranberry filling can firm up. It should resemble a jelly. Serve cold.