President Trump’s administration has been utilizing C-17 military planes for deportations since January, a move that signifies a harsh stance against migrants. A recent analysis conducted by The Wall Street Journal using aircraft and flight tracking data revealed that these military deportation flights are not only more expensive but also less efficient compared to ICE’s usual civilian deportation flights.
The WSJ’s investigation, led by Shelby Holliday, delves into the logistics of using C-17s for deportations and why this choice is costing taxpayers more money. The report highlights the stark differences between ICE Air, the agency responsible for coordinating civilian deportation flights, and the use of C-17 military planes.
The video investigation showcases a specific example of a deportation flight to India, where a C-17 was utilized for the operation, resulting in significantly higher costs. Furthermore, the report also examines the use of C-17s for flights to Guantanamo, shedding light on the inefficiencies and drawbacks of using military planes for deportations.
As a result of utilizing C-17s for deportations, ICE Air flights have seen a decline, suggesting that the use of military planes is not only more expensive but also impacting the overall efficiency of deportation operations.
The WSJ’s analysis raises important questions about the financial and operational implications of using military planes for deportations under the Trump administration. As the debate around immigration policies continues to evolve, the logistics of deportation flights have become a focal point of discussion, with taxpayers bearing the brunt of the cost.
Watch the video by The Wall Street Journal
Video “Military vs. Civilian Planes: The Logistics of Trump’s Deportation Flights | WSJ” was uploaded on 02/13/2025 to Youtube Channel The Wall Street Journal
sometimes it is not about money, it is about sending a message
I really love WSJ content, but, checkout Ryan Macbeth's video on this. You folks didn't contrast the figures with the added cost of detaining migrants for longer, if the commercial flights aren't available. ALSO, these military flights are likely to be required anyway for training purposes, so while they are expensive, they may actually represent a savings since they were going to happen anyway.
You should have at least mentioned these factors instead of ignoring them.
It's all about the fanfair and the show, he's a visual person he care about how things look more than the reality.
Trumpster is a person controlled by optics. How does it look? And if it looks good, then it's good to go.
From a former CRJ pilot – interesting.
As one with a Econ background:
Each deportation is wise gov spending, with an excellent ROI.
As each Illegal Alien costs me $75K over his lifetime.
Regardless, each military flight, or any flight, is crew training.
This time, with a purpose. There really is no substitute for in air experience.
That said, would like to to run the numbers of turbo-prop use for shorter flights.
Lower speed and range – but flight speed isn't mission critical.
what happen when you have a television personality president running the country
Elonia needs to see this video, for efficiency reasons.
lol spending money they dont have
Charter civilian planes, simple
I think it was just a message to make him look tuff on immigration policies during his first weeks of presidency. eventually will be turned back to cheaper third parties, with maybe more frequency flights? The only long term changes I think may happen will be contract extensions to third parties, so they can increase their fleet of civilian cheaper and perhaps used aircraft to expand their operations.
🛫 ConAir? 🛬
They are just showing the power Americans have.
Lets be honest if our laws were enforced in the first place this would have not happen.
They continue to cost tax payers money no matter what. Smh.
Why not using civilian planes ? ICE regularly uses rented aircrafts from commercial airlines
It’s cheaper to let them stay here.
This is a pretty biased or incompetent comparison. Important thing to remember on the military flights is the pilots need to get flight hours in. They’d be flying at least some of these hours regardless of if they are deporting illegals or not. It’s not a straight 1 to 1 comparison in reality. The real difference would be finding out how many extra flight hrs the military is using and then calculate the cost compared to the traditional flights. I’m also completely ignoring the cost to house the illegals waiting for the flights which is an important factor when calculating which costs more.
Those money goes back to our government
But if you use civilians aircrafts. They might just jack up the price for profits.
Like a prison would do. 😊
What worries me more than anything is that this affects military readiness. C-17s would be needed in a potential war with China and there’s a limited number of them. Also these flights take a toll on pilots who’s time would better spent in training
That response from the dept of gov is kinda terrifying. That's not how a gov dept should communicate.
Trips to Central and South America could easily be done by ship. Only modestly slower than by plane. Thousands of immigrants per trip at a fraction of the cost.
US is Rich 😅
If it was the regular passenger planes then there is no news value , you wouldn’t have done this program. That’s exactly the plan. This news will hit the headlines, the military flights pictures will stay in the media for a long time. One thing is for sure, for those bad actors such tactics may intimidate them and for Trump it’s a PR thing too. So it’s kind of best of both worlds
If I work for the government would it be really easy to type in any number I felt like to give a cost per flight hour?
Spin and omission are strong with this piece. Left a lot of details out that would support using the military.
This is where DOGE should be working on
Some of this cost can be justified as pilots and other crew will do a certain amount of training hours anyway, so putting them to use is cost effective but I think that a $3m trip around the world is clearly in excess to that.
ADHBHUT WSJ PRETTY COSTLY DALLAR TRUMP SANTRI AEROPLANE MASSIVE MASS ILLEGAL DEPORTEES DESTINATION TO THEIR RESPECTIVE PASSPORT NATION BUT IF THESE DEPORTEES AGAIN LEGALLY RETURN BACK TO USAUSA THEN WAT BAKWAS TIME PASS TIME WASTE DALLAR WASTE THIS IS THE WORLD SUPERPOWER HARI BOL DALLAR USAUSA DEPORTATION MAKES GREAT AGAIN
How can it cost more if we already own the plane?
Irrespective of the administration the American taxpayer is always screwed
Waste of money by trump and gop
Bc Donnie cares sooooo much about cutting costs. What a joke
Are we surprise that trump administration makes nothing but terrible choices?
That's the cost of having Sleepy Joe as your president for 4 years.
This cost comparison analysis of deportation flights is only one side of the coin. Compare that cost to the longterm cost of housing, food, health benefits, etc. at the taxpayers expense. A one time deportation flight is well worth the cost, which may save the life of potential victims as well as reduce a longterm burden on the taxpayer's dime.
You guys don’t calculate that these pilots are getting training hours during these flights. Some of these flights would be happening with or without migrants.
Ryan Macbeth covered this already
Ehhh…
Military pilots have to fly anyhow to maintain their flight hours. This is killing 2 birds with 1 stone.
If the planes were being unused, it's still a good use of a resource. The pilots are getting training hours.
Everything this guy does reeks of malevolent stupidity.
Why do the migrants get all that leg room?! /s
The Trump tracker: What the President has done so far: https://on.wsj.com/3Qe6WJz