You Don’t Know Me — Netflix doc seeks to reclaim model’s legacy, despite problematic contributors

You Don’t Know Me — Netflix doc seeks to reclaim model’s legacy, despite problematic contributors

Who was Anna Nicole Smith? In a new Netflix documentary, Anna Nicole Smith: You Don’t Know Me, director Ursula Macfarlane weaves a tragic web from complex, at times conflicting, accounts of the life of the infamous model.

You Don’t Know Me documents the unravelling of Smith’s public image, from small-town girl, to Playboy playmate and Guess model, to “gold digger” and “white trash”. From reality television star to American tragedy.

The trailer for Netflix’s Anna Nicole Smith documentary.

Born Vickie Lynn Hogan, Smith spent most of her childhood in the small Texan town of Mexia. Moving to Houston aged 19 to seek a better life to support her young son, Daniel, Smith worked as a stripper, eventually saving up enough money to afford a breast augmentation.

This surgery helped to secure her stardom as she crafted an image for herself as a larger-than-life vision of hyper femininity. But it also helped seal her fate.

Back pain from her breast augmentation led Smith to abuse prescription drugs for the rest of her life.

In 1991, while stripping in Houston, Smith met billionaire Texan oil tycoon J. Howard Marshall, who was 63 years her senior.

In return for her company, Marshall looked after Smith and her son financially. Though Smith was frequently dubbed a gold-digger in the media coverage of the couple, in You Don’t Know Me, the relationship is depicted as genuinely caring.

Smith refused to marry Marshall until she had made a name for herself. True to her word, she made herself a star and married him three years later, at Houston’s White Dove Wedding Chapel.

Smith’s star power

As with another notorious blonde bombshell of her generation, Pamela Anderson, Playboy magazine was the catalyst for Smith’s rise to fame. First featured on its cover in March 1992, Smith was quickly made playmate of the month in May, before winning playmate of the year in 1993.

Smith became one of Playboy’s most prolific models. She appeared on five US and 42 international Playboy covers, across 19 countries.

Anna Nicole Smith in a still from You Don t Know Me.
Courtesy of Netflix

Playboy led to other modelling jobs, most notoriously for fashion brand Guess. Smith’s goddess-like figure, splashed across H&M lingerie billboards, even reportedly caused a number of car accidents in Norway.

Smith’s life was also couched with tragedy. The documentary charts a lengthy and fruitless series of court cases over her deceased husband’s fortune, her brutal and misogynistic treatment in the media and both her son’s fatal overdose in 2006 and her own the following year, aged just 39.

At times the coverage of the tragedy of Smith’s life in You Don’t Know Me, eclipses that of her accomplishments.

‘Adored by millions, but loved by few’

It’s hard to get a true sense of Smith’s life and character. Her reputation has been largely shaped by a misogynistic media culture. Celebrity women are frequently criticised in the British and American press, particularly those who dare to exist outside the western norms of feminine acceptability and desirability.

In one particularly striking clip, American radio presenter Howard Stern asks Smith to be publicly weighed, for the entertainment of his viewers.

In recent years there has been a rise in re-evaluations of the treatment of female celebrities in the 1990s and 2000s. Singer Britney Spears and socialite Paris Hilton have both had documentaries made about their lives (though Spears denounced some of those made about her her via her Instagram.

Anna Nicole Smith reclines on a sofa, a copy of a book about Marilyn Monroe resting on her chest.
Anna Nicole Smith reading a book about Marilyn Monroe in a still from You Don t Know Me.
Courtesy of Netflix

Netflix has released a spate of projects on the lives of notorious blonde bombshells. In 2022, there was the controversial Marilyn Monroe biopic, Blonde, which many fans of Monroe saw as exploiting and victimising Monroe, a charge the director denied.

In 2023, a documentary in which model Pamela Anderson reclaimed her own narrative followed Hulu’s release of Pam and Tommy. The drama series, which told the story of the actor’s leaked sex tape, was created without her consent.

Read more:
Don’t watch Pam and Tommy – the series turns someone’s trauma into entertainment

These projects sometimes feel uncomfortable. It’s questionable how ethical it is to retell the story of women whose lives have already been damaged by media depictions of them. Instead of redeeming their subjects, these projects often cause further harm by perpetuating a sense of public ownership over them.

Who gets to tell Smith’s story?

While Macfarlane successfully calls attention to how unfairly the media treated Smith, it’s troubling how the documentary treats Smith’s lawyer, Howard K. Stern with neutrality.

Stern was accused of being complicit in the drug abuse that led to her death. He was found guilty of illegally providing Smith with prescription drugs in 2009, before having his conviction overturned in 2011.

Her doctor, Sandeep Kapoor, who was acquitted of over-prescribing drugs to Smith in 2010, is also featured in the documentary, describing how he pulled strings to provide a heavily pregnant Smith with methadone in the Bahamas.

In his 2017 memoir, Trust Me, I’m A Doctor: My Life Before, During and After Anna Nicole Smith, Kapoor claimed that while he knew Smith misused drugs, he wasn’t aware of her addiction.

Anna Nicole Smith dressed in a Marilyn Monroe style white halter neck dress, surrounded by journalists.
Anna Nicole Smith dressed as Marilyn Monroe in a still from You Don t Know Me.
Courtesy of Netflix

Smith’s ex-boyfriend Larry Birkhead and their 16-year-old daughter Dannielynn Birkhead refused to take part in the documentary, saying that they withdrew over disagreements with production over who would or would not be its participants. Birkhead claims to be working on his own documentary of Smith’s life, utilising her archives to “let Anna tell her own story”.

You Don’t Know Me presents the pieces of a complicated legacy. Though the cultural fascination surrounding Smith means audiences are eager to learn about the “real her”, she is (unlike Spears, Hilton and Anderson) no longer alive to tell her own story – or refute those told about her.

The post “You Don’t Know Me — Netflix doc seeks to reclaim model’s legacy, despite problematic contributors” by Daisy McManaman, PhD Candidate, Centre for Women’s Studies, University of York was published on 05/16/2023 by